BOURGEAU'S CLASSIC MYSTERY BOOKS
In his Mystery Lovers Companion of 1986, Art Bourgeau uses a rating scheme of one to five daggers to indicate the quality of the work he lists and briefly describes. The Mystery Lover's Companion reviews and rates some 2500 books. His highest rating, five daggers, is used to indicate “A True Classic.” These Classics are listed below
 The Woman in White | Wilkie Collins | 1860 |
 The Moonstone | Wilkie Collins | 1868 |
| The Leavenworth Case | Anna Katharine Green | 1878 |
 The Mystery of a Hansom Cab | Fergus Hume | 1886 |
 Pudd'nhead Wilson | Mark Twain | 1894 |
| The Scarlet Pimpernell | Baroness Orczy | 1905 |
| The Man Who Was Thursday | C.K. Chesterton | 1908 |
| The Innocence of Father Brown | C.K. Chesterton | 1911 |
 Trent's Last Case | E.C. Bentley | 1913 |
 The Lodger | Marie Belloc Lowndes | 1913 |
| The Wisdom of Father Brown | C.K. Chesterton | 1914 |
 The Thirty-Nine Steps | John Buchan | 1915 |
 The Haunted Bookshop | Christopher Morley | 1919 |
 The Mysterious Affair at Styles | Agatha Christie | 1920 |
| The Great Impersonation | E. Phillips Oppenheimer | 1920 |
 The Red House Mystery | A.A. Milne | 1922 |
| John McNab | John Buchan | 1925 |
 The Mousetrap | Agatha Christie | 1925 |
 The Murder of Roger Ackroyd | Agatha Christie | 1926 |
 The Chinese Parrot | Earl Derr Biggers | 1926 |
 The Canary Murder Case | S.S. Van Dine | 1927 |
 Meet Mr. Mulliner | P.G. Wodehouse | 1927 |
| The Footsteps at the Lock | Ronald A. Knox | 1928 |
 The Greene Murder Case | S.S. Van Dine | 1928 |
| The Poisoned Chocolate Case | Anthony Berkeley | 1929 |
 Red Harvest | Dashiell Hammett | 1929 |
| The Roman Hat Murder | Elery Queen | 1929 |
 Mr. Pottermack's Oversight | R. Austin Freeman | 1930 |
 The Maltese Falcon | Dashiell Hammett | 1930 |
 Arundel | Kenneth Roberts | 1930 |
 Strong Poison | Dorothy Sayers | 1930 |
 Green Ice | Raoul Whitfield | 1930 |
| Death Walks in Eastrepps | Francis Beeding | 1931 |
| The Living Shadow | Maxwell Grant | 1931 |
| The Shadow Laughs | Maxwell Grant | 1931 |
 Malice Aforethought | Francis Iles | 1931 |
 Five Red Herrings | Dorothy Sayers | 1931 |
 Keeper of the Keys | Earl Derr Biggers | 1932 |
| Death Under Sail | C.P. Snow | 1932 |
| Darkness at Pemberly | T.H. White | 1932 |
 Was it Murder? | James Hilton | 1933 |
| An Oxford Tragedy | J.C. Masterman | 1933 |
 Rabble in Arms | Kenneth Roberts | 1933 |
 The Postman Always Rings Twice | James M. Cain | 1934 |
 Murder on the Orient Express | Agatha Christie | 1934 |
 The Nine Tailors | Dorothy Sayers | 1934 |
 Fer-de-Lance | Rex Stout | 1934 |
 The Mystery of Cape Cod Tavern | Phoebe Atwood Taylor | 1934 |
| The Chinese Orange Mystery | Elery Queen | 1934 |
 Thank You, Jeeves | P.G. Wodehouse | 1934 |
 The Three Coffins | John Dickson Carr | 1935 |
 Enter a Murderer | Ngaio Marsh | 1935 |
 The League of Frightened Men | Rex Stout | 1935 |
| Wax | Ethel Lina White | 1935 |
 Thou Shell of Death | Nicholas Blake | 1936 |
| The Beast Must Die | Nicholas Blake | 1936 |
 The ABC Murders | Agatha Christie | 1936 |
 This Gun for Hire | Graham Greene | 1936 |
| Northwest Passage | Kenneth Roberts | 1936 |
 The Lady Vanishes | Ethel Lina White | 1936 |
 Hamlet Revenge! | Michael Innes | 1937 |
| Rebecca | Daphne DuMaurier | 1938 |
 Ship of the Line | C.S. Forester | 1938 |
 The Stoneware Monkey | R. Austin Freeman | 1938 |
 Lament for a Maker | Michael Innes | 1938 |
| Death from a Top Hat | Clayton Rawson | 1938 |
 The Code of the Woosters | P.G. Wodehouse | 1938 |
| A Coffin for Demetrios | Eric Ambler | 1939 |
| No Orchards for Miss Blandish | James Hadley Chase | 1939 |
 And Then There Were None | Agatha Christie | 1939 |
 Rogue Male | Geoffrey Household | 1939 |
| The Mysterious Mickey Finn | Eliot Paul | 1939 |
| Footprints on the Ceiling | Clayton Rawson | 1939 |
 Oliver Wiswell | Kenneth Roberts | 1940 |
| The Bride Wore Black | Cornrll Woolrich | 1940 |
 Mildred Pierce | James M. Cain | 1941 |
| A Pinch of Poison | Richard & Francis Lockridge | 1941 |
| The Black Curtain | Cornrll Woolrich | 1941 |
 Payment Deferred | C.S. Forester | 1942 |
| Laura | Vera Gaspary | 1942 |
| Cue for Murder | Helen McCloy | 1942 |
 Calamity Town | Ellery Queen | 1942 |
 The Black Angel | Cornell Woolrich | 1942 |
 The Lady in the Lake | Raymond Chandler | 1943 |
 The Ministry of Fear | Graham Greene | 1943 |
 Holy Disorders | Edmund Crispin | 1945 |
 The Rising of the Moon | Gladys Mitchell | 1945 |
| The Red Right Hand | Joel Townley Rogers | 1945 |
 The Moving Toyshop | Edmund Crispin | 1946 |
 The Big Clock | Kenneth Fearing | 1946 |
| The Double Take | Roy Huggins | 1946 |
| Ride the Pink Horse | Dorothy B. Hughes | 1946 |
| The Pavilion | Hilda Lawrence | 1946 |
| Devil Take the Blue Tail Fly | John Franklin Bardin | 1948 |
| The Skeleton in the Clock | Carter Dickson | 1948 |
| Sudden Fear | Edna Sherry | 1948 |
| I, the Jury | Mickey Spillane | 1948 |
 Rendezvous in Black | Cornell Woolrich | 1948 |
 The Little Sister | Raymond Chandler | 1949 |
 Buried for Pleasure | Edmund Crispin | 1949 |
| Cat of Many Tails | Ellery Queen | 1949 |
 The Third Man | Graham Greene | 1950 |
 Strangers on a Train | Patricia Highsmith | 1950 |
 In a Lonely Place | Dorothy B. Hughes | 1950 |
| My Gun Is Quick | Mickey Spillane | 1950 |
 To Love and Be Wise | Josephine Tey | 1950 |
 The Daughter of Time | Josephine Tey | 1951 |
| The Tiger in the Smoke | Margery Allingham | 1952 |
| The Ivory Green | Rocc Macdonald | 1952 |
 The Killer Inside Me | Jim Thompson | 1952 |
| Meatball | Frederick Brown | 1953 |
 The Long Goodbye | Raymond Chandler | 1953 |
 The Night of the Hunter | Davis Grubb | 1953 |
 A Kiss Before Dying | Ira Levin | 1953 |
 The Black Mountain | Rex Stout | 1954 |
 A Hell of a Woman | Jim Thompson | 1954 |
| Wilders Walk Away | Herbert Brean | 1955 |
| Beast in View | Margaret Millar | 1955 |
 The Talented Mr. Ripley | Patricia Highsmith | 1956 |
| Landscape for Dead Dons | Robert Robinson | 1956 |
 Our Man in Havana | Graham Greene | 1958 |
 Anatomy of a Murder | Robert Traver | 1958 |
 Psycho | Robert Bloch | 1959 |
| The List of Adrian Messenger | Philip McDonald | 1959 |
| Watcher in the Shadows | Geoffrey Household | 1960 |
 The Rose of Tibet | Lionel Davidson | 1962 |
 The Ipcress File | Len Deighton | 1962 |
| Seven Days in May | Fletcher & Bailey | |
 The Zebra-Striped Hearse | Ross Macdonald | 1962 |
| How Like an Angel | Margaret Millar | 1962 |
| The Will of the Tribe | Arthur W. Upfield | 1962 |
 The Spy Who Came in From the Cold | John Le Carre | 1963 |
 Ice Station Zebra | Alistair MacLean | 1963 |
 The Emperor's Pearl | Robert Van Gulik | 1963 |
| Funeral in Berlin | Len Deighton | 1964 |
| The Liquidator | John Garner | 1964 |
| The Night of the Generals | Hans Helmut Kirst | 1964 |
| The Minuteman Murder | Jane Langton | 1964 |
 This Rough Magic | Mary Stewart | 1964 |
 Pop, 1280 | Jim Thompson | 1964 |
| Winter of Madness | David Walker | 1964 |
| In the Heat of the Night | John Ball | 1965 |
| Who Is Lewis Pinder? | L.P. Davies | 1965 |
 The Quiller Memorandum | Adam Hall | 1965 |
 The Doorbell Rang | Rex Stout | 1965 |
| The Double Image | Helen MacInnes | 1966 |
| Green Grow the Tresses-O | Stanley Hyland | 1967 |
| The Seersucker Whipsaw | Ross Thomas | 1967 |
 Necklace and Calabash | Robert van Gulik | 1967 |
| The Laughing Policeman | Sjowall & Wahloo | 1968 |
 Flashman | George MacDonald Fraser | 1969 |
 Puppet on a Chain | Alistair MacLean | 1969 |
 The Godfather | Mario Puzo | 1969 |
| The Fire Engine that Disappeared | Sjowall & Wahloo | 1969 |
 Time and Time Again | Jack Finney | 1970 |
 The Day of the Jackal | Frederick Forsyth | 1971 |
 The Friends of Eddie Coyle | George V. Higgins | 1971 |
| Bear Island | Alistair MacLean | 1971 |
 The Underground Man | Ross Macdonald | 1971 |
| Blood on a Harvest Moon | David Anthony | 1972 |
 The Rainbird Pattern | Victor Canning | 1972 |
 The Odessa File | Frederick Forsyth | 1972 |
 The Eiger Sanction | Trevanian | 1972 |
 The Defection of A.J. Lewinter | Robert Littell | 1973 |
 The First Deadly Sin | Lawrence Sanders | 1973 |
 The Death of the Detective | Mark Smith | 1973 |
| If You Can't Be Good | Ross Thomas | 1973 |
| The Plot Against Roger Ryder | Julian Symons | 1973 |
 The Loo Sanction | Trevanian | 1973 |
 Jaws | Peter Benchley | 1974 |
 The Dogs of War | Frederick Forsyth | 1974 |
 Tinker, Tailor, Soldier, Spy | John Le Carre | 1974 |
 The Dreadful Lemon Sky | John D. MacDonald | 1974 |
 Other Paths to Glory | Anthony Price | 1974 |
 The Onion Field | Joseph Wambaugh | 1974 |
 The Eagle Has Landed | Jack Higgins | 1975 |
| A Big Enough Wreath | William Gardner | 1975 |
| Stealing Lilian | Tony Kenrick | 1975 |
 The Eye of the Tiger | Wilbur Smith | 1975 |
| The Cavanaugh Quest | Thomas Gifford | 1976 |
| The Boys from Brazil | Ira Levin | 1976 |
| Someone Is Killing the Great Chefs of Europe | Nan & Ivan Lyons | 1976 |
| Best Martin Hewitt Detective Stories | Arthur Morrison | 1976 |
 Cry Wolf | Wilbur Smith | 1976 |
 Flashman's Lady | George MacDonald Fraser | 1977 |
| Charlie M. | Brian Freemantle | 1977 |
| The Punch and Judy Murders | George Hart | 1977 |
 A Judgement in Stone | Ruth Rendell | 1977 |
 Flyaway | Desmond Bagley | 1978 |
 The Last Good Kiss | James Crumley | 1978 |
 The Eye of the Needle | Ken Follett | 1978 |
| The Death Freak | Irving & Bukholz | 1978 |
| The Random Factor | La Rosa & Tannenbaum | 1978 |
| The Mobius Strip | William Gardner | 1979 |
 Shibumi | Trevanian | 1979 |
| The Fifth Horseman | Collins & LaPierre | 1980 |
 Congo | Michael Crichton | 1980 |
| Mantis | Peter Fox | 1980 |
| Mr. American | George MacDonald Fraser | 1980 |
| A Woman Called Scylla | David Gurr | 1981 |
| Paragon Walk | Ann Perry | 1981 |
 Red Dragon | Thomas Harris | 1981 |
| The Queen's Messenger | W. R. Duncan | 1982 |
 Twice Shy | Dick Francis | 1982 |
| The Heights of Rimring | Duff Hart-Davis | 1982 |
 Fatal Vision | Joe McGinniss | 1983 |
| Dolly and the Bird of Paradise | Dorothy Dunnett | 1984 |
| The King's Commissar | Duncan Kyle | 1984 |
| The Tragedy at Tiverton | Raymond Paul | 1984 |